Law Updates

Subject

Summary: A new service business in Haryana that is paying interest on a term loan or working-capital loan may now have access to some relief, provided it falls within the categories covered by the State Government's new scheme. The notification regarding the interest subvention scheme was issued by the Industries & Commerce Department, Haryana, on 9 September 2026 for setting up new Micro and Small Enterprises in the services sector. This scheme has been included in the implementation of the RAMP Program by Haryana. This scheme provides relatively specific financial aid in terms of 2% interest subvention, which is capped at 5 lakhs per annum of term loan or loan for working capital requirements. However, it does not necessarily mean that every MSE will get 5 lakhs. It should satisfy certain criteria, fill out the application form, and pass through the scrutiny process.  What Is the Haryana Interest Subvention Scheme for Service Sector MSEs? The scheme is meant to reduce a part of the interest cost borne by eligible new service businesses in Haryana. "Interest subvention" means that the government supports a specified portion of the interest burden. The underlying loan does not disappear. The borrower remains responsible for repayment to the bank, financial institution, or NBFC. Under this scheme, eligible service-sector MSEs may receive support calculated at 2%, subject to the annual ceiling of 5 lakh rupees and the other conditions written into the notification.  It should not be confused with: a loan waiver,  an interest-free loan,  a grant available to every MSME,  a direct 5 lakh rupees payment, or  a scheme covering all kinds of businesses.  The nature of the business, date of commencement, loan date, lender, Udyam status, and past subsidy claims all matter. How Is the Scheme Connected With the RAMP Programme? The notification places the scheme within Haryana's Strategic Investment Plan under the RAMP Programme. According to the notification, RAMP was launched by the Government of India with World Bank support to improve MSME performance. The programme focuses on areas such as market and credit access, stronger institutions, better Centre-State coordination, delayed-payment issues and greening of MSMEs.  For Haryana, this particular scheme uses that broader programme to support service-sector Micro and Small Enterprises through interest relief. Why Has Haryana Introduced the Scheme? The stated objective is to address financing challenges faced by smaller service businesses. The notification specifically refers to: improving access to finance,  reducing borrowing costs for service-sector MSEs,  encouraging investment in the service economy,  promoting business growth,  supporting job creation, and  contributing to wider economic and inclusive development.  The practical benefit is easy to understand. A newly established service business may need external finance before its operations stabilise. Even a partial reduction in interest cost can ease some of that pressure. Whether a particular business receives the benefit, however, depends on the scheme conditions. How Much Interest Subsidy Can a Service-Sector MSE Receive? The scheme offers 2% interest subvention, with assistance capped at 5 lakh rupees per financial year. That headline figure needs to be read carefully. The 2% is the Rate of Interest Support The scheme does not offer 2% of turnover, profit, or investment. It relates to interest on the qualifying loan. Annexure II reinforces this by requiring the lender to certify the loan, the applicable interest, and the amount that works out at 2% for the relevant period.  5 Lakh rupees is the Upper Limit 5 lakh rupees is the maximum annual amount. It is not a flat payout. If the admissible interest support is lower than 5 lakh rupees, the business cannot claim the ceiling merely because it is eligible for the scheme. Only One Loan Category Can Be Used The notification gives a choice between: a term loan, or  a loan taken for working-capital requirements.  Assistance cannot be claimed on both.  For businesses with more than one borrowing arrangement, this point needs to be checked before preparing the claim. Who Can Apply for the Haryana MSE Interest Subsidy? The broad eligible category is new service-sector Micro and Small Enterprises in Haryana. But that description alone is not enough. The notification adds several conditions. Basic Eligibility Conditions A business should check whether: it is classified as a Micro or Small Enterprise,  it operates in the service sector,  the activity falls within the eligible service list,  it is not a trading unit,  it qualifies as a "new enterprise",  the relevant loan meets the scheme's date condition,  the loan is from an eligible financial institution, bank or NBFC,  it holds a valid Udyam Registration Certificate,  it is in regular commercial operation,  it is not a defaulter or NPA with a bank,  it has not already taken a conflicting interest-subvention benefit,  it does not fall in the State Government's restrictive list,  applicable NOC, CLU or CTO requirements have been met, and  the claim is complete and filed within the prescribed period.  Several of these checks are factual. A business either meets them or it does not. That is why an eligibility review should normally be completed before the application form is filled. How Does the Notification Define a Micro Enterprise? For this scheme, the notification describes a Micro Enterprise as one where: investment in plant and machinery or equipment does not exceed 2.5 crore rupees, and  turnover does not exceed 10 crore rupees.  It also refers to amendments made by the Government of India under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 from time to time.  How Does the Notification Define a Small Enterprise? A Small Enterprise is described as an enterprise where: investment in plant and machinery or equipment does not exceed 25 crore rupees, and  turnover does not exceed 100 crore rupees.  The notification again makes this subject to Government of India amendments under the MSMED Act.  Applicants should therefore check the classification actually applicable when the claim is being made rather than relying on an old internal classification. What Counts as a New Enterprise? One date matters repeatedly in this scheme: 1 April 2025. The notification defines a "new enterprise" as an enterprise that commenced commercial production or operations on or after 1 April 2025.  This is not the date on which the scheme itself was notified. The scheme notification came later, on 9 September 2026. That distinction matters because businesses need to check both: when commercial operations started, and  when the relevant loan was sanctioned or disbursed.  Which Service Businesses Are Covered? The notification gives an express list of service activities. Service Activity Position Under the Scheme Health Care Covered Tourism Covered, except stand-alone hotel/restaurant facilities Skill Development Covered Training-cum-Incubation Centres Covered Information Technology Covered Bulk Courier Services Covered R&D Centres Covered Testing Laboratories Covered Engineering & Design Services Covered Equipment Rental & Leasing Covered where related to construction and industry Equipment Maintenance & Repair Covered Environmental Services Includes sewage/waste disposal/management Entertainment Parks Covered, except Cinema Halls Other Services May be included later if notified by the State Government The eligible list appears in the scheme's definition of a service enterprise.  Are Trading Businesses Eligible? No. Trading units are expressly excluded. A business should therefore not assume that Udyam Registration or Micro/Small classification is enough by itself. What About Stand-Alone Hotels and Restaurants? The tourism category is included, but the notification specifically excludes stand-alone hotel/restaurant facilities from that entry.  A hospitality business should examine its exact activity before preparing a subsidy claim. Are Cinema Halls Covered? No, not under the Entertainment Parks entry. The source includes Entertainment Parks but excludes Cinema Halls.  Can Haryana Add More Services Later? Yes. The notification says other service enterprises may also be included if the State Government notifies them from time to time.  Which Loans Can Be Considered for the Subsidy? Two types of business borrowing are recognised. Term Loan An eligible term loan can form the basis of the claim where all other conditions are met. This may be relevant where a business has borrowed for business assets or longer-term operational requirements, depending on its loan arrangement. Working-Capital Loan A qualifying working-capital loan may also be considered. This is particularly relevant for service businesses that rely on borrowed funds for recurring business expenditure. The scheme, however, does not allow support for both categories together. Which Lenders Are Covered? The notification refers to loans taken from: Financial Institutions recognised by the Government of India,  Co-operative Banks,  Sarv Haryana Kshetriya Gramin Bank,  Commercial Banks, and  NBFCs.  The general guidelines also indicate that the loan should be in the name of the firm and used for business operational purposes.  Why Is 1 April 2025 Important for the Loan? The scheme does not look only at the business commencement date. The loan also has to satisfy the prescribed date condition. The notification says that a service enterprise whose term loan or working-capital loan was sanctioned/disbursed on or after 1 April 2025 may be admissible under the scheme. It also provides a specific exception-like situation: where a term loan was sanctioned before 1 April 2025 but disbursed after 1 April 2025, the applicant can still be eligible.  This makes the disbursement date particularly important. Businesses should therefore review the original sanction letter and bank disbursement records rather than relying on memory or accounting entries. Important Dates and Timelines Event Timeline Why It Matters New enterprise condition Commercial operations on or after 1 April 2025 Used to determine whether the business is "new" Loan eligibility date Relevant sanction/disbursement on or after 1 April 2025 Used to test financing eligibility Notification date 9 September 2026 Scheme notified from this date Application claim period Within 3 months from close of relevant financial year, subject to the notification wording Missing the period may affect entitlement Deficiency communication Within 7 days Applicant may receive a portal notice Deficiency correction 10 days Applicant must respond quickly Approval/rejection Within 30 working days from application Stated processing period Appeal Within 30 days from communication of order Available against HOD order Delay condonation by HOD Up to 3 months after prescribed limit Not automatic Delay condonation by Administrative Secretary Up to 6 months after prescribed limit Requires satisfactory reasons/evidence Important Clarification Required on Scheme Duration One part of the notification deserves special attention because the wording is not consistent. Under the section dealing with Quantum of Assistance, the benefit is described as available for three years from the notification or until the validity of the RAMP Programme in Haryana, whichever is later.  But under Commencement and Applicability, the notification says the scheme will remain operational for three years from notification or until the validity of RAMP, whichever is earlier.  Those two phrases can produce different results. Therefore, companies cannot conclude a final date of closure merely on the basis of a single clause. In case the validity of the scheme is related to the claim, then any formal statement issued by the Government of Haryana /Industries & Commerce Department will be relevant. When Does an Enterprise Have to File the Claim? The claim is not open-ended. The notification states that an enterprise can forfeit its entitlement if it does not submit a complete claim within three months of the closing of the financial year for which the incentive is claimed or from the notification date, whichever is later.  The word "complete" is important. Submitting only the online form without the required supporting records may not be enough if the application remains deficient. How to Apply for the Haryana Interest Subvention Scheme The process is laid down in the notification itself. Step 1: Check Whether the Business Fits the Scheme Before filing, review: enterprise size,  service activity,  date of commencement,  loan type,  sanction and disbursement dates,  lender,  Udyam Registration,  repayment status, and  other subsidy claims.  This first check can prevent an ineligible or conflicting claim from being filed. Step 2: Fill the Prescribed Application The application form in Annexure I needs to be filled in by the applicant. This form will require the following particulars: details of the trade, Udyam particulars, loan particulars, and amount of subsidy claimed. Step 3: Collection of Supporting Documents The required supporting documents need to be collected. A bank certificate and CA certificate form part of this documentation. Step 4: Submit the Claim Online The application is to be filed through the web portal of the Directorate. The notification text does not expressly provide the portal URL. Step 5: Wait for Scrutiny The office of the HOD, Directorate of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises, Haryana, examines the application and recommends approval or rejection after review.  Step 6: Respond if a Deficiency Is Raised Where the Directorate identifies a deficiency, it is to be communicated through the portal within 7 days. The applicant then has 10 days to correct it. If the deficiency is not removed within the prescribed time, the claim is to be closed, and the applicant will not be entertained again for that claim.  Step 7: Approval or Rejection The notification states that the application is to be approved or rejected within 30 working days from the date of application.  This is the timeline written in the scheme; it should not be read as a promise that every filed application will result in approval. Documents Required for the Haryana Interest Subsidy Claim The document list is not generic. Annexure I identifies the papers that have to accompany the application. Document Why It Is Required Status Latest Udyam Registration Certificate Confirms MSME registration and category Required Incorporation/Partnership/LLP/Co-operative registration proof Confirms legal constitution As applicable CLU/NOC Shows relevant approval If applicable Board Resolution/Power of Attorney Confirms authorised signatory As applicable Loan sanction letter Establishes financing details Required Declaration regarding other interest subvention Checks duplication of benefit Required Bank/FI/NBFC Certificate – Annexure II Confirms loan and interest details Required CA Certificate – Annexure III Confirms investment details Required GST Return/Audited Balance Sheet Supports financial information If applicable Non-default/NPA undertaking Confirms repayment status Required What Information Is Required in Annexure I? Annexure I is the main claim form. It seeks details such as: Applicant and Business Details name of authorised applicant,  enterprise name and address,  contact information,  registered office,  constitution of the business,  GST number, and  block in which the enterprise is located.  MSME and Operational Details Micro or Small category,  Udyam Registration number and date,  date of commencement of commercial operations, and  nature of services provided.  Loan Details bank, financial institution or NBFC,  sanctioned term-loan or working-capital amount,  actual rate of interest,  date and amount of first disbursement, and  interest subsidy being claimed for the relevant financial year.  Because these particulars are capable of being cross-checked, applicants should make sure the form matches the bank records, Udyam certificate, and financial statements. What Does the Bank Certificate Have to Confirm? Annexure II requires a certificate from the concerned bank or financial institution. The certificate is designed to verify the financial details behind the claim. It covers matters such as: amount of term loan or working-capital loan sanctioned,  rate of interest,  sanction date,  amount disbursed,  first disbursement,  repayment during the relevant financial year,  interest paid,  amount calculated at 2%,  regularity of repayment, and  whether penal interest has been charged.  This is why the applicant should coordinate with the lender before the claim deadline rather than leaving the bank certificate until the last moment. What Is the Chartered Accountant Certificate For? Annexure III requires a Chartered Accountant to certify the enterprise's investment details. The format refers to: registered office,  operational location,  investment as on the relevant date,  turnover of the previous financial year,  CA membership number, and  UDIN.  The Chartered Accountant verifies the financial information. The CA does not sanction the government incentive. What Does Annexure IV Require? Annexure IV contains the applicant's undertaking and declaration. It is to be submitted on non-judicial stamp paper and sworn before a Notary Public or First-Class Magistrate, as specified in the notification.  The applicant declares, among other things, that: information supplied is correct,  similar assistance has not improperly been taken,  excess assistance may be refundable, and  incorrect or misleading statements can result in refund and other consequences.  The declaration also refers to a refund with 12% compound interest per annum where the circumstances specified in the undertaking arise.  How Are Applications Prioritised? The scheme does not simply create an unlimited pool of assistance. Complete applications are prioritised based on their date of submission on the portal, and the benefit remains subject to availability of budget.  This gives businesses a practical reason to prepare their records early. Waiting until the last permissible date may leave less time to deal with a missing bank certificate or another document issue. How Does the Directorate Scrutinise an Application? Once the application is filed, the Directorate examines the claim rather than immediately releasing the benefit. The office of the HOD is responsible for scrutiny and for recommending approval or rejection. The process can therefore involve: filing of the claim,  document scrutiny,  identification of any deficiency,  rectification by the applicant,  evaluation of the completed claim, and  approval or rejection.  The notification further says an applicant should not normally be asked to submit documents other than those specified in Annexures I, II and III unless additional material is needed to establish the genuineness of the claim.  What Happens if a Deficiency Is Found? Applicants need to watch the portal after filing. The scheme gives a relatively short period for correcting errors. Deficiency Notice A deficiency, if any, is to be communicated on the web portal within 7 days. Time to Correct It The applicant gets 10 days to rectify the points raised. Failure to Respond If the deficiency is not removed within that period, the claim is to be closed.  This makes post-filing follow-up almost as important as preparing the initial application. Who Has the Power to Sanction the Subsidy? The HOD, Directorate of Micro, Small & Medium Enterprises, Haryana, is the competent authority for sanction of assistance after completion of the required formalities.  The bank only verifies the loan information. A consultant may assist with documentation. Neither performs the government's sanctioning function. Who Can Clarify the Scheme? The Administrative Secretary, Industries & Commerce Department, Haryana is authorised to issue interpretations or clarifications and remove difficulties relating to the scheme.  That provision becomes especially relevant because of the inconsistent "whichever is earlier/later" wording relating to scheme duration. Can an Applicant Appeal a Rejection? Yes. An applicant can challenge an order passed by the HOD before the Administrative Secretary, Industries & Commerce Department, Haryana. The appeal has to be filed within 30 days from the date the order is communicated. The Administrative Secretary's appellate order is stated to be final.  What if the Application Is Filed Late? The scheme does provide some room for condonation of delay, but late filing should not be treated casually. Delay Up to Three Months The HOD, Directorate of MSME, Haryana may condone delay up to three months after the prescribed filing period. Delay Up to Six Months The Administrative Secretary can condone delay up to six months after the prescribed period. This longer condonation depends on the authority being satisfied with the reasons for late submission, supported by substantial evidence, documents or arguments.  Condonation is therefore discretionary, not automatic. Can an Applicant Shift to Another Subsidy Scheme Later? Not for the same component in the manner restricted by this notification. The scheme says an applicant who has already applied under it cannot migrate to another scheme for the same component. It gives the example of an enterprise taking benefit under this scheme for one year and later seeking to move to the Interest Subsidy Scheme under HEEP 2020 or another industrial policy. Such migration is not permitted under the stated rule.  Businesses comparing more than one incentive should therefore assess the options before committing to a claim. Can the Same Business Claim Similar Benefits Under Another Scheme? The notification also blocks duplicate similar assistance. An applicant under this scheme cannot claim a similar benefit under another State or Central Government scheme. A declaration has to be submitted confirming that such similar assistance has not been taken. If verification shows otherwise, the entire assistance may have to be refunded.  This should not automatically be read as a ban on every other government incentive. The issue is overlapping or similar benefit for the relevant component. What Happens if Wrong Information Is Given? This is one area where the notification uses strict language. If assistance has been claimed on the basis of wrong facts, the scheme provides for consequences that can include: refund of the assistance,  12% compound interest per annum,  legal action,  debarment from State Government incentives or assistance,  recovery as arrears of land revenue if the amount is not refunded, and  debarment from public procurement where facts and figures do not match.  Applicants should therefore check all figures, loan details, and declarations before submission. Pre-Application Checklist for Service-Sector MSEs Before filing, a business should be able to answer the following questions clearly: Check What the Business Should Confirm Enterprise category Is it Micro or Small? Business activity Is it an eligible service activity? Trading activity Is the business excluded as a trading unit? Start of operations Did commercial operations begin on or after 1 April 2025? Loan date Does sanction/disbursement satisfy the scheme? Lender Is the loan from an eligible institution? Udyam Is the certificate valid and updated? Operational status Is the business currently operating? Loan account Is it free from default/NPA status? Other incentives Has similar interest support already been claimed? Approvals Are NOC/CLU/CTO available where applicable? Bank certificate Can Annexure II be obtained? CA certificate Can Annexure III be completed? Deadline Is the claim within the prescribed period? What Are the Main Benefits for Eligible MSEs? The value of the scheme lies mainly in reducing part of the financing cost. For a qualifying business, it may help with: Lower Eligible Interest Burden A 2% subvention can reduce part of the interest cost attached to the qualifying loan. Support During the Early Business Stage Because the scheme focuses on new enterprises, the benefit may be particularly relevant when a service business is still building revenue and managing fixed financial commitments. Coverage of Working-Capital Borrowing The scheme is not restricted only to long-term finance. Eligible working-capital borrowing is also recognised. Support for Formalised Businesses Udyam Registration, proper bank records, and documented financial information are central to the claim. That naturally favours businesses maintaining organised records. These benefits remain conditional. The scheme does not guarantee profitability, revenue growth, or approval of the full 5 lakh rupees amount. Conditions Businesses Should Not Miss The headline benefit can look attractive, but several conditions can change the outcome of a claim. Businesses should pay particular attention to: service-sector eligibility,  Micro or Small classification,  exclusion of trading units,  exclusions within specific service categories,  commercial-operation date,  sanction and disbursement date,  one-loan-category restriction,  Udyam Registration,  operational status,  NPA/default status,  similar subsidy claims,  budget availability,  annual claim deadline,  documentation requirements,  10-day deficiency period, and  correctness of declarations.  The scheme is therefore better approached as a documented financial claim rather than a simple subsidy form. Business Impact of the Haryana Interest Subvention Scheme New Service-Sector MSEs These businesses are the main intended beneficiaries. For them, the scheme can reduce part of the cost of borrowing, but eligibility depends on both the business and the loan meeting the notified conditions. Businesses With Term Loans If the dates of the loan and disbursement fall under the scheme, then companies funding their long-term requirements by term loans could also be eligible for assistance under it. Businesses using Working Capital The introduction of working capital loans has made the program more practical to use, particularly by businesses whose ongoing expenses necessitate financial support from banks. Trading Businesses Trading units remain outside the scheme. That exclusion needs to be identified at the beginning rather than after documents have already been prepared. Businesses Already Receiving Interest Support These applications require a further check, as there may be some other State/Central Government benefit scheme which might clash with the said scheme. Banks/NBFCs The lenders themselves do not approve the schemes; however, they are important for making a case, as Annexure II relies on them. Practical Challenges Businesses May Face Some parts of the scheme are straightforward. Others may need closer checking. Determining Whether a Service Is Covered The listed activities are specific. A business offering a mixed service model may need to determine where its actual activity fits. Checking Loan Dates The scheme makes a distinction between sanction and disbursement. That can affect a business whose loan was approved before 1 April 2025 but released later. Getting the Bank Certificate on Time The bank certificate contains several figures and confirmations. Applicants may need time to obtain it from the concerned branch. Avoiding Conflicting Subsidy Claims Businesses using more than one government scheme should compare the benefits before signing the non-availment declaration. Responding Quickly to Deficiencies Ten days is not a long period if the missing item has to come from a bank, accountant, or government authority. Scheme-Duration Ambiguity The "whichever is earlier" and "whichever is later" difference should be watched for an official clarification. What Should Businesses Do Next? A practical approach would be: Check Micro or Small classification.  Confirm that the activity is covered.  Verify the date of commercial operations.  Review the sanction and disbursement dates in the loan documents.  Confirm the lender is covered.  Check Udyam Registration details.  Review any earlier or current interest-subsidy benefits.  Collect applicable NOC, CLU, or CTO documents.  Request the prescribed lender certificate.  Arrange the CA certificate.  Complete Annexure I carefully.  Submit the application within the prescribed period.  Keep checking the portal after filing.  Respond quickly if a deficiency is raised.  The order matters because an eligibility problem found at the start is much easier to deal with than one discovered after the application has been filed. How Can Corpseed Help With the Haryana MSE Interest Subsidy Scheme? Applying for a government incentive often involves more than uploading a few documents. In this scheme, the enterprise category, service activity, start date, loan records, Udyam details, and earlier subsidy claims all need to fit together. Corpseed can provide MSME subsidy consultancy services to businesses that need support in checking these requirements and preparing a structured application. 1. Scheme Eligibility Assessment Corpseed can review whether the business appears to meet the basic scheme conditions, including: Micro or Small classification,  service-sector activity,  new-enterprise date,  term-loan or working-capital condition,  lender category,  Udyam Registration, and  restrictions on similar benefits.  This helps identify an eligibility issue before the application reaches the filing stage. 2. MSME Subsidy Application Support Through MSME subsidy application support, Corpseed can assist with organising the prescribed application and supporting information according to the scheme. The service can include a review of whether the details entered in Annexure I match the underlying records. Approval remains entirely with the competent Haryana Government authority. 3. Subsidy Documentation Assistance The claim depends on several supporting records. Corpseed can assist businesses in reviewing: Udyam Registration Certificate,  entity registration documents,  loan sanction letter,  applicable NOC or CLU,  declarations,  financial records,  lender certificate, and  supporting application papers.  The purpose is to reduce avoidable mismatches before filing. 4. Bank Certificate Coordination The Annexure II certificate has to come from the concerned bank, financial institution, or NBFC. Corpseed can help the applicant understand the prescribed information so that the business knows what needs to be requested from the lender. 5. CA Certificate Support Annexure III requires certification from a Chartered Accountant. Corpseed can assist the business in organising the underlying information needed for the certificate, while the certification itself remains the responsibility of the CA. 6. Government Subsidy Consultancy Businesses already using another government incentive may need to understand whether the benefit overlaps with the Haryana interest subvention scheme. A government subsidy consultancy review can help businesses compare the relevant conditions before making a declaration or choosing between similar incentives. 7. Deficiency Response Support In the event that the Directorate puts up the deficiency notice on the website, Corpseed can help the applicant understand the problem and organize the response as required. This will be especially useful when the deficiency is in regard to loan documents, certificates, or conflicting information on different documents. 8. Ongoing MSME Compliance Support The business will require assistance with the MSME record-keeping, Udyam information, and the documentation for the government incentives as well. Corpseed's MSME incentive consultancy and related compliance support can be used where these services match the business's actual requirements. Key Takeaways Haryana notified the scheme on 9 September 2026.  It applies to qualifying new Micro and Small service-sector enterprises.  Trading units are excluded.  The scheme provides 2% interest subvention, capped at 5 lakh rupees per year.  Assistance can be claimed on either a term loan or a working-capital loan, not both.  1 April 2025 is important for both the enterprise and loan-related eligibility conditions.  Udyam Registration, bank documents, and prescribed certificates form an important part of the claim.  Similar interest benefits under other State or Central Government schemes cannot be duplicated in the manner prohibited by the notification.  Missing the filing deadline or the failure to remedy any defect would have an impact on the claim. The notification uses contradictory "whichever is earlier/later" language regarding the scheme duration; therefore, it is necessary to seek further explanation from the officials on this issue.